Are there concrete hints of a Montblanc Limited Edition on Goethe?

Concrete and confirmed hints of a Goethe edition did not exist at the time of the discussion; even enquiries at Montblanc boutiques remained without result. Such an edition is among collectors regarded as an obvious idea, e.g. within the framework of the Writers Edition, but has so far not been announced. Anyone wishing to follow current rumours on coming Limited Editions finds these, by experience, early in the forum of fountainpennetwork.com.


Are there at Montblanc counterfeits with plastic housings or are the counterfeits restricted to lacquered metal housings?

Montblanc counterfeits with resin or plastic housings have existed for some time, even if lacquered metal housings are more frequently encountered. A known example is the counterfeit of the Limited Edition Kafka, which also consists of resin. With the counterfeit of the Greta Garbo, even a new, significantly improved nib variant was discovered that comes very close to the original. The quality of the imitations thus continuously rises also in the area of materials and nibs, which makes identification for laypersons increasingly difficult.


From what period does a green-marbled Montblanc Meisterstück with the patent number DRP 508058 and the marking 30 at the barrel end come?

It is the Meisterstück Stylo number 30, made between 1930/31 and 1934; the barrel number 30 refers to the then retail price of 30 Reichsmark. From the factory the model was originally not a fountain pen with nib but a push filler with stylo tip, to which the patent number mentioned unambiguously points. Often the black front part with the stylo tip was subsequently exchanged for a grip section with nib. On the green-marbled celluloid housings, discolourations as well as material shrinkages additionally often occur.


Can one judge from unsharp photos whether a Montblanc 144 is genuine or a counterfeit, and can converters from other manufacturers fit?

A reliable authenticity check is not possible without sharp, detail-rich photos; especially the imprints on the nib must be clearly recognisable. A clear warning sign in the present judgement was a converter that unambiguously did not come from Montblanc. Converters of other makes can mechanically fit but do not speak for an original set. Imprints like Germany on the clip alone do not deliver authenticity proof.


Is the Montblanc Soulmakers 100 Anniversary Bohème offered on eBay a counterfeit?

The writing instrument is genuine; it is the officially issued Bohème 1906 Edition for the 100-year company jubilee of Montblanc. Further information and illustrations can be found at fountainpen.de on the page on the Anniversary 100 Bohème 1906. The model is actually comparatively little known, which can cause uncertainty in sales.


How can a damaged Montblanc Le Grand ballpoint with a hole in the star or a scratched 146 be repaired?

Repairs on Montblanc writing instruments are basically carried out only directly by the manufacturer; a spare-parts sale to end customers does not take place. The repair prices are, compared to other manufacturers, however moderate. Sensible is a call to Montblanc customer service in order to obtain a cost estimate in advance. The writing instrument can then either be sent in directly or given via a specialist retailer for repair, with the latter possibly entailing additional costs.

General questions on writing instruments


Where can one obtain the collector's book The List on Montblanc writing instruments, and how is its quality to be assessed?

The book is as a reference work, despite some weaknesses, unique; criticised, however, are the partly disproportionate illustrations and the mediocre picture quality, which can give laypersons a wrong impression of the writing instruments; an improved new edition is planned but temporally still open. Source is mostly Regina Martini, who offers the book regularly in her eBay auctions. Most recently the price was around 12.50 euros plus postage. Alternatively, Mrs Martini can also be enquired about directly.


Is a used Montblanc Meisterstück 164P for 129 euros via a classified ads platform a good purchase?

Whether the price is reasonable depends decisively on the actual condition and the completeness (original box, service guide). The provider named is known from eBay and has there already sold numerous allegedly near-new 164Ps, which gives cause for caution; queries about the origin of the pieces were not reliably answered. An authenticity check after purchase is therefore urgently recommended. Basically: with doubtful sources, one should keep one's hands off the deal, provided the authenticity and origin are not clarified beyond doubt.


What factual information was given on the C.A.S. collectors' get-together on 25 February 2007 in Dortmund?

The C.A.S. collectors' get-together took place on Sunday, 25 February 2007, from 14:00. The venue was the restaurant Zum Franziskaner, Düsseldorfer Str. 21, 44143 Dortmund (telephone 0231/586 21 18). In the restaurant, the possibility existed to take a lunch at one's own expense, although the kitchen was closed between 15:00 and 17:00. In total, eleven collectors took part.


What background and sources are there on the mentioned online video about fountain pens?

The video stands in connection with an article from the customer magazine of Deutsche Bank in the November issue, in which investment possibilities in the area of writing instruments are reported. Mentioned in it is also the work of the C.A.S.; the magazine used photos made available by the C.A.S. The corresponding report can be read as a PDF on pages 34 to 37 of the corresponding issue.


Which reputable sources for high-quality Montblanc pens as a birthday gift are there on the internet?

Recommendable online sources for Montblanc writing instruments are the official Montblanc website with direct ordering possibility as well as the dealers fuellhalter.de, onlinehandel-AS.de and especially missing-pen.de from Rolf Thiel. The latter is classified as very recommendable. On the mentioned site liebl.exklusives-schreiben.de, no own experiences were available, so no evaluation could be given on it.


How does one correctly reply in the forum to a post, so that the reply is properly assigned to the original entry?

In order for a reply to be correctly sorted under the corresponding post, the reply button must be used, which stands directly under the respective post. There, at the bottom right, are the buttons Reply and Quote. If, instead, a button above the post is used, the reply can be sorted incorrectly.


Where can information be found on sales periods and original prices of Montblanc writing instruments from 1980 onwards like Traveller, Noblesse, Slim Line or Carrera?

The standard work Collectible Stars by Stefan Wallrafen covers writing instruments only up to 1979 and therefore offers no complete data for the desired models of the 1980s; some devices are additionally missing there entirely. A suitable point of contact for historical catalogues and supplementary information is Stefan Wallrafen himself, who has(d) extensive material but has in recent years given up holdings. Even if some models were produced longer than stated, the production periods named in the book are reliable for most devices. Original dealer catalogues from the period 1980 to 1985 are the most reliable source for exact sales periods and prices.


How high is the approximate value of a Montblanc Year of the Golden Dragon to be estimated?

Two different Year of the Golden Dragon exist: an edition of 2000 pieces as well as an edition of 888 pieces (among others in Meissen porcelain); additionally there are Special Limited Editions. The launch price of the 2000 edition was between about 2400 and 2800 euros. The variant with Meissen porcelain had a list price of around 3850 euros. As a utility pen, the model is only restrictedly suitable because of the very massive clip; as a collector's piece, however, attractive.


Where can one cheaply obtain original refills for the Montblanc Meisterstück Classique Line?

Outside eBay, bargains on original refills are hardly to be found, since mail-order dealers with such low-value articles often do not allow the minimum order value and prices online hardly differ from specialist trade. On eBay, 10-packs are occasionally offered; here, however, caution is in order, since refills are now also being counterfeited. Anyone wanting to be safe therefore buys best from the authorised specialist retailer or from Montblanc itself.


Can a Montblanc pen bought as Edition Chopin with 18-carat gold nib be identified as an original and the correct model?

The fountain pen described is genuine, but it is not the Meisterstück 145 Chopin but the cheaper, meanwhile discontinued Meisterstück 144. An 18-carat gold nib indicates that the piece was originally intended for the French market, since 14-carat gold nibs are not permitted there. The longitudinally ribbed feed without lamellas is typical of older models; newer devices have lamellas on the feed. A matching piston converter can be bought in specialist trade for under 10 euros. On the 144 it is also normal that the cap bears neither a serial number nor a Pix embossing on the inside of the clip.


Which corporate colours did Soennecken use between 1910 and 1925 for the packaging of its writing utensils?

A uniform corporate colour cannot be evidenced for Soennecken in this period; the available historical documents are often only available in black and white. Soennecken used various colours for different products, apparently without a recognisable system, and also printed the company inscription in different colours on the packaging. A systematic colour code for the nib boxes or distribution packagings is therefore not handed down. Since Soennecken today belongs to the brand group Branion and no own company museum exists, detailed information is difficult to obtain.


Which Montblanc leather case from an eBay auction could it be if it is not findable online anywhere?

An unambiguous identification of the case was not possible in the forum. The supposition that it could be the leather sleeve for the Leonardo Sketchpen was rejected based on a direct comparison photo. Possibly it is a free case from a special campaign, which given the unfindability in the regular range appears plausible. For large writing instruments above the LeGrand, such cases offer anyway no sufficient protection.


Which Montblanc is suitable as an everyday companion up to 500 euros, and what is known about the Lennon rollerball and the announced Hitchcock edition?

The choice between fountain pen, ballpoint and rollerball is strongly personal; a rollerball is, however, basically well everyday-suitable. Prices in specialist trade deviate only insignificantly from the recommended retail price, so the Lennon rollerball at around 510 euros lies in the usual range. On the announced Hitchcock special edition, no concrete pictures or prices were available at the time of the discussion. Special Editions are only made in a limited period and are after sell-out generally only obtainable via the collector market.


How old is a Montblanc Pix push pencil really, and how is its preservation condition to be evaluated?

The push pencil Pix was made from 1935 to 1950 and is thus rather between 70 and 80 years old, not older. On the example described, on the push button the cover as well as the clip are missing; the piece is therefore incomplete. Comparison photos of a complete pencil of this type can be found on fountainpen.de under old-72-mechanical-pencil.htm.


Which writing instrument is an expensively auctioned supposed Montblanc vintage piece?

The piece is not a Montblanc but an extremely rare coral-red Pelikan, which explains the high auction price. Only the clip comes from Montblanc; the nib is from an unknown manufacturer. It is therefore an assembled pen whose value is based solely on the rare Pelikan housing.


How does one clean and care for the silver surfaces of Montblanc Limited Editions, e.g. on the Charles Dickens, Kafka or Fitzgerald, without causing damage?

Tarnishing silver surfaces is a normal chemical reaction and for many collectors visually unproblematic. For cleaning, a common silver-cleaning cloth is suitable, ideally with anti-tarnish protection for longer effect; Montblanc also offers its own silver-care set. To be considered is that every polish removes material, no matter which manufacturer; with vermeil writing instruments, too frequent polishing can wear off the gilding, e.g. on the Oscar Wilde. The natural oxide layer additionally acts as a protective layer that on removal restarts the corrosion process. A sealing with lacquer would be theoretically conceivable but would bring other disadvantages with it.


Which tools are suitable for disassembling old fountain pens, especially for loosening stuck piston mechanisms or nibs?

For disassembly, pliers with jaws plastic-coated on both sides are recommended, as also used in the automotive area for spark plugs; such pliers cost from about 14 euros and are available under search terms like spark plug and pliers, alternatively via Tom Westerich from penboard.de. The advantage is the even pressure from all sides, which prevents splintering on the barrel. Stuck feeds with nib are better loosened by longer soaking, ultrasonic treatment (immerse only the grip section) as well as careful warming with a hair dryer; on hard rubber, only heat should be used. Stuck nibs can, after removal of the piston mechanism, be knocked out with a matching HSS drill (shaft first, light blows with a rubber hammer) and a hardwood block with drilled holes as a counter-support.


Which Montblanc model is an angular, partly matted and shiny gold ballpoint with the engraving Mont Blanc Germany?

Without a photo, a reliable determination is not possible; based on the description, the model fits most likely the Montblanc Leonardo Da Vinci. It is not a Limited Edition but an entirely normal ballpoint from the 1990s. Caution is in order if on the pen really Mont Blanc Germany is written separately, since the manufacturer spells itself Montblanc; such a spelling speaks clearly for a counterfeit. For final clarification, it is recommended to post photos in the forum.


Can the steel bracelet of a Montblanc Star Large Automatic be extended, and where can one obtain individual links?

The extension seems to prove more difficult on the Montblanc steel bracelet than on many other brands; a new bracelet costs, according to dealer information, around 370 euros minus the clasp. In current dealer catalogues numerous clasp variants are listed, but individual links for bracelet extension are not to be found there. The metal bracelets are apparently delivered in the three sizes medium, large and XL. It is recommended to contact Montblanc customer service directly, since the similar procedure with other renowned watch manufacturers shows that procurement of individual links can be complicated or expensive; links kept when shortening are therefore valuable.


What background information is there on the writing-instrument brand Goldring, whose clip bears this inscription?

The brand Goldring was a rather small German manufacturer; corresponding works existed in Leipzig and in Bühl. Before the Second World War, in Germany thousands of writing-instrument manufacturers existed, so smaller brands like Goldring are only difficultly assignable. For a more precise determination, photos of the writing instruments are helpful. Supplementary information can be found occasionally on eBay as well as in the forum penexchange.de.


Which model is a Montblanc ballpoint with the inscription METAL2 and Pix engraving under the clip, and is it genuine?

It is a Solitaire 164 Doué; the inscription METAL2 without 925 hallmark indicates that the pen consists of gilded brass and not of vermeil (gilded silver). Montblanc later replaced the vermeil version with gilded brass, since vermeil tarnishes with time and the gilding can become spotted. The Pix engraving under the clip is entirely normal: Pix was originally Montblanc's brand name for mechanical pencils and was later used on further writing instruments too, because the brand Meisterstück was not protectable in all countries. Pix is therefore frequently found on rings of various Meisterstücks and is no indication of a counterfeit.


Should one as an everyday pen choose a Montblanc ballpoint or rollerball, and which alternatives come into consideration?

The choice is strongly a matter of taste; a rollerball is, because of the cap and the visual proximity to the fountain pen, often preferred, while the StarWalker appears to some too modern. Particularly popular as an everyday rollerball is the Meisterstück Le Grand. From the view of writing culture, however: ballpoints have an unfavourable effect on handwriting; rollerballs even more strongly. Anyone who cannot or does not want to use a fountain pen should rather choose a click pencil with 0.9 mm lead for notes.


How is one to deal with sellers who suddenly offer counterfeit writing instruments from apparently hacked eBay accounts?

Currently, hacked eBay accounts are being used in increased numbers in order to offer, often inferior, counterfeits originating from China; affected are not only Montblanc writing instruments but also brand products like Louis Vuitton, Gucci, Fendi and Nokia mobile phones. eBay can hardly keep up with deleting such auctions, and help for affected account holders is primarily only offered via English-language live chat. Striking is when an account suddenly offers completely different articles than before, which points to a takeover. Recommended is a daily check of one's own eBay account in order to recognise unnoticed third-party activities early. The eBay toolbar is said to offer some protection but does not replace regular checking.


Does an enquiry of the serial number to the manufacturer offer certainty whether a Montblanc bought in a shop is genuine or a counterfeit?

A mere enquiry of the serial number to the manufacturer does not deliver certainty, since even counterfeits can be provided with fictitious serial numbers and Montblanc, without inspection, gives no authenticity statement. Certainty is given only by sending the writing instrument to Montblanc; genuine pieces are returned, counterfeits disposed of. By now also very well-made counterfeits exist that are not distinguishable from originals at first and second glance but hardly turn up in reputable shops. An experienced specialist, however, reliably recognises these counterfeits.


Does a timeline for dating the Montblanc Meisterstück 149 analogous to the timeline for the 146 exist?

Helpful online resources for dating the Meisterstück 149 are a PDF in the blog whitestar_ftl on livedoor.jp as well as the thread Dating Montblanc 149s in the forum of fountainpennetwork.com. With the help of these overviews, models can be classified quite precisely temporally based on structural features. For example, a bicolour 14K nib combined with a two-part barrel, brass filling mechanism and ebonite feed points to a production time between 1985 and 1990.


Where can one have an old Pelikan ballpoint repaired if the stationery dealer can no longer perform this?

Enquiries on repairs of old Pelikan ballpoints are better placed in the forum penexchange.de, since there more Pelikan collectors and accordingly relevant specialist knowledge are to be found. Specialised collectors often know repairers who can also restore older models.


How high was the original new price of the Cartier Art Deco Dandy?

The Cartier Art Deco Dandy had at sales start a new price of 810 euros. The model is now sold out and is regarded as a comparatively sought-after collector's piece within the Cartier writing instruments. On the current collector price, however, no concrete information is available.


How should the forum deal with enquiries in which model identification is linked with the actual goal of a value determination for sale?

Striking is the frequency of combined enquiries about model and value that ultimately aim at a planned sale, without communicating this openly. Factual questions about model designation, age or production period are gladly answered in the forum, because the hobby rests on mutual information exchange. Pure price and value enquiries are by contrast usually referred to corresponding forum notice posts or deliberately left unanswered. Recommended is to continue giving factual information but to consistently exclude value questions.


Where was a three-piece Montblanc Franz Kafka Limited Edition set available at a special price in 2007?

The complete three-piece Kafka set was offered in August 2007 for 1350 euros minus 3 percent discount. Source was Papeterie Prygoda, Augustastraße 10, 45525 Hattingen, telephone 02324/22796.


Can an old Montblanc lever filler with heart-hole nib, star marking 6 and Simplo imprint be more precisely dated and identified based on the description?

The fountain pen is most likely genuine; heart-hole nib, feed and barrel imprint speak for a manufacture towards the end of the 1920s. The cap seems somewhat shortened, and also the lever appears not to be original, since the correct lever had the Montblanc star engraved on the round lever end. Regarding the stated size 6, it is a comparatively rare model. A definitive determination requires further detail photos, especially of the barrel end and any further engravings.


Of which stainless steel does the Montblanc 144 Solitaire Stainless Steel actually consist, and how is the alloy composed?

The material used is the standardised stainless steel 316 L, which with only 0.03 percent carbon counts as exceptionally low in carbon; the L in the name stands for low carbon. Vanadium is, contrary to some older descriptions, not contained. The typical composition reads around 17 percent chromium, 12 percent nickel, 2.5 percent molybdenum, 2 percent manganese, 1 percent silicon as well as the rest iron. Steel grades are identified internationally via material numbers, whereby the DIN designations are the clearest and can be looked up in relevant material tables. The webpage on the 144 Stainless Steel was corrected after this hint.


Which diaries and refill books exist in Montblanc's Diaries & Notes collection, in which colours, sizes and prices, and are there ruled inserts from third parties?

Montblanc also offers ruled refill books for the Diaries & Notes collection, which in boutique specialist trade was temporarily not correctly communicated. The individually available books cost without the expensive leather cover around 21.50 euros and have a plain black cardboard cover with silver star, so only the inner book has to be exchanged when it is fully written. The paper is ink-fast enough for common fountain-pen inks of various manufacturers; bleed-through occurs only in exceptional cases. The price lies clearly above commercially available notebooks, which with intensive daily use is a cost factor. Concrete size variants and colour specifications (e.g. black instead of only red, mustard, caramel) were not finally named in the thread; an on-site appointment in the boutique is therefore recommended.


Is a Montblanc piston filler offered on eBay without a model statement on the middle ring a 144 or 145, and how does one recognise original or counterfeit?

The models 144 and 145 are exclusively cartridge fillers; a piston filler is therefore either a 146 or a 149. The model number is not necessarily engraved on the middle ring, so the absence of such an inscription is no authenticity criterion. Piston fillers like 146 or 149 are because of the elaborate mechanism usually not counterfeited, unlike the 145, of which there are by now very good copies. With suspicion of a counterfeit, a detail photo of the nib is worthwhile, paying attention to flat-engraved script and correctly seated rings. In case of doubt one should refrain from the bid and request pictures from the seller.


What is the Montegrappa Peace Pen and why is it regarded as record-breaking?

Montegrappa has presented with the Peace Pen a fountain pen of platinum with large diamonds. The announced retail price of 1,000,000 US dollars makes it a candidate for the Guinness Book of Records. By comparison, classical models like a Meisterstück 144 or 164 seem price-wise negligible. A large view of the piece was viewable via the Vogue Gioielli website.


Can a gilded Safety filler with the inscription "ASTORIA FABRICAT" be an Astoria or Montblanc-Astoria filler?

Without a picture, the exact assignment can hardly be made. Astoria, however, made alongside Safety models also lever fountain pens in different sizes, among others in size 1, partly also with overlay. A designation "Montblanc-Astoria" could not be clarified in the thread; for a reliable determination photos should be posted.

Related pages on fountainpen.de:
• Astoria — brand overview (fountainpen.de): https://www.fountainpen.de/astoria-en.htm


What are the experiences with the Montblanc ink "Je t'aime Love letters Ink" and with scented inks or scented postage stamps in general?

The rose-scented ink "Je t'aime Love letters Ink" is, even after thorough cleaning with water, often still long perceptible in the fountain pen, which many users find disturbing. Overall, the enthusiasm for scented inks has cooled in the hobby circle, since the smell stubbornly remains in the writing instrument. As an alternative, the wine inks by Jansen are mentioned, whose scent is more discreet, is only slightly perceived during writing and does not permanently perfume the fountain pen. A combination with scented postage stamps is seen critically and counts rather as a burden for the addressee and postal delivery.


Is the blue ink-view window of a Montblanc fountain pen from the 1950s (e.g. model 042/342) originally blue or does the colour come from dried ink?

The ink-view windows of the 1950s models like 342 or 042 were made at the factory of transparent blue plastic; a blue tone is therefore normal. Whether an allegedly "never filled" pen really is ink-free is difficult to ascertain externally; colour deviations at the transition to the grip section can indicate ink residues. When buying such pieces, scepticism towards seller statements is therefore in order. Especially from eBay providers in Singapore and neighbouring regions, due to frequent negative experiences, is advised against.


Why do buyers bid on obviously counterfeit Montblanc writing instruments on eBay partly high amounts, and how should one behave as a buyer?

Even clearly recognisable counterfeits regularly achieve three-figure bids on eBay, because buyers often do not inform themselves sufficiently or deliberately speculate on a supposed bargain price. A geographical concentration e.g. in the new federal states cannot be evidenced; location indications can be set arbitrarily. Basically, prepayment on eBay bears a high risk, since the effort to enforce rights in case of dispute mostly exceeds the goods value. Anyone not wanting to pay the boutique price must calculate the risk of being cheated. Safe procedure are careful checking of the pictures, research of the model features and avoiding obvious plagiarisms.


How can one judge after an eBay purchase whether a Montblanc Meisterstück 144 is genuine?

Based on the posted auction pictures a tendency can often already be recognised; a serious authenticity check, however, requires the pen in hand. In the specific case, the piece depicted on the photos seemed original, which however does not rule out that after shipping another example is delivered. Therefore one should after receipt carefully compare the delivery with the auction pictures and, in case of deviations, use the eBay buyer-protection deadlines.


Does the Montblanc Meisterstück No. 149 exist with both 14-carat and 18-carat gold nibs?

On the Meisterstück 149, both 14-carat and 18-carat gold nibs were actually fitted. The variant depends on the year of manufacture and country of destination and can also overlap within a series. A 14-carat nib is therefore no indication of a counterfeit. Overviews of the various 149 variants can be found in collector databases like pentrace.com as well as in older forum posts.


What does a minus sign after the nib width (for example "B-") on an old Montblanc 149 from the 1950s mean?

If the sign really looks like a minus, the thread gives no unambiguous explanation. If the sign rather looks like a small "L", it is a special left-hander nib with a one-sided flattened tipping. A detailed overview of nib markings and their meanings can be found in newsletter No. 1 of 2005.


Are the briefcases shown in a particular online offer really original Montblanc products or counterfeits?

The briefcases linked in the post are counterfeits. They are sold via corresponding dubious sources. A purchase of such pieces is therefore advised against.


Which ID number and which price does the round Montblanc bookmark with punched-out logo have?

The ID number 08723 is correct; the non-binding recommended retail price is 45.00 euros. Sources are authorised specialist retailers, e.g. the renowned online provider scription.de for high-quality writing instruments and accessories.


When and where does the CAS collectors' get-together Dortmund take place in April 2005?

The second CAS collectors' get-together 2005 took place on 10 April 2005 at 14:00 (lunch from 13:00) in the restaurant "Zum Franziskaner" at Düsseldorfer Str. 21, 44143 Dortmund. The kitchen of the restaurant is closed between 15:00 and 17:00. Registrations and queries were possible via the email address Fuellhalter2004@yahoo.de. A short report on the meeting was subsequently published in the forum under the section "Sammlertreffen".


Are there Montblanc fountain pens that were used as door handles, and how often are these still to be found today?

Such oversized Montblanc fountain pens as door handles exist and are highly sought-after among collectors, but extremely rare and correspondingly expensive. On eBay they turn up only at larger time intervals, then at high prices. The pieces are massive (presumably brass) and generally have no clip; on the back there are two fastening holes, which makes them unsuitable as a stand model. A known example was located at Kölner Gürzenichstr. 7 (today Füllfeder-Zentrale Kellner & Sohn).


What are the adjustable nibs from an old architect's compass set and what were they used for?

They are ruling pens that were dipped in India ink and used with a wooden grip for technical drawing. Without a wooden grip, they can be fitted to a compass in order to draw precise circles of nearly any line thickness. The nib is always drawn diagonally over the tracing paper, which is why taking up too much India ink must be avoided, since otherwise unsightly blots can arise. Such devices belonged to the standard equipment in the architecture training of the 1970s.


Why is no ink-view window recognisable on the Montblanc Meisterstück 144G from the year 1952, and how can this be remedied?

All 144s from the 1950s were made with a viewing window; a model without a window did not exist. The celluloid of the window can, however, darken strongly over the course of decades and appear dark red to almost black. Dried ink residues inside can also visually close the window. Multi-day flushing with water often brings the window better into view again; with moderate water hardness, tap water suffices; otherwise distilled water is recommended.


Is there a public directory of the codes on Montblanc clips for unambiguous model determination?

A publicly accessible directory of the clip codes does not exist. The codes serve Montblanc as an internal authenticity feature and are deliberately encoded so that only the company can fully read out the information. Publication would undermine the purpose of this coding, especially with regard to counterfeits from China.


Is a Montblanc Meisterstück ballpoint acquired on eBay with a serial number on the upper ring and Pix engraving genuine?

Based on the pictures shown, the ballpoint appears genuine. Authenticity features are, among others, the Pix engraving, the clean rotary mechanism for extending the refill as well as correctly seated rings and engravings on the upper ring. For reliable confirmation, high-resolution detail shots of all relevant spots are necessary.


Did Montblanc actually have service guides in the unusual get-up shown in the eBay auctions?

The packaging depicted and the service guide correspond to a variant used by Montblanc in the early 1990s. The combination is therefore consistent and no indication of a counterfeit.


How can stains on the gilded clips of Cross writing instruments be removed without damaging the pen?

Cross writing instruments have a lifetime warranty that also covers the free refurbishment of stained or damaged clips. The simplest way is therefore to send the pen directly to Cross or to have it sent there via the specialist trade with a small processing fee and postage reimbursement. Own polishing attempts are not necessary and bear the risk of damaging the surface.


What experiences are there with fountain pens by Nakaya?

Nakaya fountain pens are described as very good writers. An ordered variant without clip in Tamenuri lacquer becomes somewhat redder in the course of time and develops its own patina. Photos often only insufficiently reproduce the actual colour character of such lacquers.


Is the leather of a particular offered Sienna case an unusual variant or the normal version?

The case shown is the normal Sienna leather version in Italian leather and looks genuine. Really rare are, by contrast, variants of ostrich leather (Anniversary 75) as well as of mastic leather; the latter never officially came on the market and existed only as a prototype at Seeger.


What is known about the first issue of the limited Montblanc "Presidential Pen" range on George Washington?

The edition "George Washington" is the first issue of the Presidential Pen range and limited to 50 examples. Distribution is exclusively via Montblanc boutiques in the USA. Collectors evaluate the look predominantly positively but criticise the presumably very high price and partly the textual staging. Further information and pictures can be found via kulturgutschrift.de. Awaited with anticipation is the subsequent Marlene Dietrich issue, which is regarded as more accessible price-wise.


How is the Montblanc Magical Black Widow 88 to be acquired and what price is called up for it?

The Magical Black Widow 88 is hardly to be found in Germany, since only about two to three examples were sold to Germany; the majority went to the USA. An international search, e.g. via English-language collector forums, is therefore more promising. Privately called-up sale prices move in the range of around 30,000 euros. The piece No. 1/88 was additionally offered at a Bonhams auction in Los Angeles in February 2009.


Is an old Montblanc fountain pen offered on eBay with an untypical clip a real Montblanc, and if so which model?

The fountain pen is a real Montblanc; the unusually designed overlay, however, does not come from Montblanc but from the Stuttgart jeweller MAENNER. MAENNER refined in the 1930s writing instruments of various brands (Montblanc, Pelikan and others) with silver or gold work and supplemented partly matching pencils with the same overlay. These pieces were officially distributed via the field staff and stationery dealers of the brands and delivered in original cases, in whose lid lining "MAENNER Stuttgart" stood. Such refinements are sought-after collector pieces today.


How is an eBay shop to be evaluated that uses the same original pictures for many models and demands payment via Western Union?

From such providers it is urgently advised against. eBay expressly warns against payments via Western Union, since via this no buyer protection exists. Even the promise of a purchase-price refund in case of complaint helps no further if the goods are not even shipped or a postal address is missing. The uniform use of pictures for all models (e.g. regardless of the plating) is a typical feature of disreputable shops. Even if the depicted original pictures look genuine, one should refrain from such auctions.


Which model is a Montblanc piston filler with converter bought on eBay, is it genuine and how does one remedy failures during writing?

Based on the pictures, it is a Montblanc 145 (Chopin/Classique) with piston converter; a counterfeit it is not according to the pictures provided. Writing failures often arise through ink deposits, especially if black ink was used previously, since it contains more suspended particles than blue ink. Helpful is, at every ink change, to flush the fountain pen with warm water and thereby keep the ink channels free. With longer writing breaks, it is recommended to fill the converter halfway with water and insert it, so that the ink line does not dry out. Platinum-plated 145s are very sought-after on the second-hand market and accordingly achieve high prices.


Why does the Montblanc 144 Doué Hematite have a screw thread on the cap, unlike the normal 144, and is posting the cap on the metal barrel during writing sensible?

Most Solitaire 144 variants have a screw thread, since a screwed connection is more durable and all current Meisterstücks are uniformly constructed. Early Solitaire Ramses models still had a plug-on cap; due to the high barrel weight, however, this loosened easily, which is critical with precious-metal barrels. When posting the cap on the back of a metal barrel, scratching of the surface is additionally threatened, which is why this is advised against; the cap lip itself can also take damage, as is often observed with old Safety pens. Such Solitaire pieces are anyway rather jewellery pieces than robust utility devices. For writing without the cap posted, additionally, the fact speaks that the Hematite thereby does not become too rear-heavy.


What is to be made of the Montblanc John Lennon Edition (limited and unlimited versions), and does John Lennon thematically fit a Montblanc luxury pen?

The John Lennon Edition appears in several variants, including an unlimited issue as well as a version limited to 1940 pieces. From 2010 the pieces are available; whether they will also be offered in Germany was open at the time of the discussion. The light, silver colouring is felt by some collectors as rather feminine. In content, the thematic connection between John Lennon and Montblanc is seen critically, similarly to previously with the Mahatma Gandhi Edition, because the reference between personality and luxury fountain pen feels far-fetched. The name reference recognisably serves as justification for higher prices of limited editions.


Which range does a completely black Montblanc fountain pen with "Bosch" imprint on the cap come from, and how old could it be?

An exact model determination is not possible without pictures. Montblanc made in the 1980s and 1990s writing instruments for Bosch and other companies with individual advertising imprint as special versions. The fountain pen is therefore likely to come from this period and is a regular series version personalised by advertising imprint.


What is known about the Montblanc edition "Hommage à Max Reinhardt 2005" for the Salzburg Festival?

The edition "Hommage à Max Reinhardt 2005" supported the Young Directors Project of the Salzburg Festival. It was exclusively available during the festival (25 July to 31 August 2005) in the Montblanc boutique Salzburg (Alter Markt 1). The worldwide edition was 30 examples, 10 pieces per colour variant.


Are Montblanc Solitaire Doué fountain pens now also being counterfeited, and how does one recognise a counterfeit?

On a Solitaire Doué shown in the discussion, the star on the cap appears unusually angular and "jagged", differently than on the original with clearly rounder points. A comparison with the cap of a guaranteed genuine Solitaire 144 Stainless Steel confirms this difference. Added to this are a hardly credible nib design that rather recalls models of the 1950s, an unsharply taken photo and a seller with only few ratings. Before a purchase, additional detail photos should be requested; in case of doubt, the auction is to be advised against.


How can in Berlin old Montblanc and other writing instruments from an inheritance (including Monte Rosa, Sheaffer, Lamy) be correctly assessed and sold?

The pieces described are predominantly not particularly valuable utility and school fountain pens, e.g. with the Monte Rosa a school fountain pen from the 1950s. Value surprises are therefore not to be expected. In Berlin, the collectors Fritz Diesbach and Ulrich Krüner are regarded as reputable contacts for evaluation and sales advice; contact is possible via the telephone book. A professional evaluation on the spot helps to achieve realistic prices and to market writing instruments correctly.


Why does a link to the picture gallery of the 45 Meisterstück on fountainpen.de not work, although the menu was allegedly corrected?

The original link contained an error; correctly it reads old-30er- instead of old-20er. Even after correction on the server, it can take 24 to 48 hours until changes are visible to all users. The reason for this are proxy servers e.g. of Telekom, which cache static web pages and thereby deliver buffered between server and end user. In the meantime, many browsers therefore still display the old or faulty version of the page.


Is the tendency to stage the ballpoint as an art object also transferable to fountain pens, and which artists are known to work with fountain pens?

While the ballpoint is increasingly taken up as material of modern art projects (e.g. in exhibitions like "The Biro Limited Edition"), the fountain pen remains so far largely untouched. Artistic work with the pen, however, plays a role: architect Helmut Jahn uses, according to Montblanc Chronicle, always a good dozen Montblanc fountain pens for designing his buildings and executes his sketches with brown sepia ink. Such original drawings now achieve high prices on the art market, which underlines the importance of the pen as an artistic tool.


How can one judge from photos whether a Montblanc rollerball is genuine?

Based on the posted photos, the rollerball shown appears original. A final authenticity check is, however, beyond pictures only safely possible in hand, since details like engraving depth, material weight and mechanism must be judged.


What consequences does the ECJ ruling on the distribution of luxury articles have for online dealers and collectors, and how is it evaluated?

With the ruling, the ECJ strengthens the rights of branded-article manufacturers by recognising the luxurious aura as an essential quality feature. Thus manufacturers may more strongly steer the distribution of high-quality brands, by which online trade and especially discount or third-party platforms can be restricted. Collectors see this critically, because tendencies emerge that manufacturers want to push back the trade of own second-hand goods, and platforms like eBay as a marketplace are endangered. In the discussion, an eBay petition for restriction-free online trade was therefore also supported. The complete ruling text the ECJ provides under the file number C-59/08.


How high is the sale value of an inherited Montblanc Hemingway fountain pen in used but good condition?

For a serious value statement, two points are decisive: whether it is the ballpoint or the fountain pen and whether the original packaging and the special service guide are present. Both have a considerable influence on the achievable price, since complete sets are traded significantly higher. In the specific case, it is a fountain pen without packaging and without service guide; a concrete price range was not finally named in the thread.


Can a leaking Montblanc 242G with a dried-out cork seal be repaired oneself, or is it sensible to use only the nib further?

A 242G is collector-wise not particularly valuable; the gold nib, on the other hand, is very beautiful; if the writing tipping is missing, the nib is, however, unusable. A self-repair is not recommended for laypersons, because work on the old material can quickly lead to a total loss. Montblanc itself no longer repairs these old models due to a lack of spare parts; restorations are taken on exclusively by specialised restorers, who have to demand corresponding prices. A proper restoration is worthwhile above all with culturally and historically more significant pieces; on the 242, it is economically to be weighed.


Which retail price is realistic for a Montblanc Meisterstück 742 in Rolled Gold?

A serious price statement is hardly possible without a photo and condition description, since the preservation condition is decisive. As a rough indication, an example in good condition most recently achieved around 200 euros on eBay. Further information on value determination can be found in older forum posts on comparable models.


What did the Montblanc set "300 Years St. Petersburg" with the Patron of Art Editions Peter & Catherine the Great cost, and how are the sets numbered?

In May 2003, Montblanc compiled 300 St. Petersburg sets from remaining stock of the Peter & Catherine 4810 edition as well as 100 sets from the 888 stock. The 4810 sets cost 2,970.00 euros, the solid-gold 888 sets 8,670.00 euros; the individual editions lay at 1,483.00 euros (4810) or 4,334.00 euros (888). The edition numbers are not running consecutively from 1 to 100/50 but resulted coincidentally from the remaining stock; however, the pen pairs within a set are always equally numbered. The sets were delivered in special outer packaging with description and leaflet, the 100 solid-gold sets in a special wooden box; distribution took place exclusively via Montblanc boutiques worldwide. Critically seen is when boutiques later significantly higher prices (e.g. 9,100 euros for a Catherine 888) adapt to individual auction results and thereby suggest an artificial increase in value.


How and where does one best sell a Montblanc set like the Imperial Dragon 1993?

For the sale of high-quality writing instruments, three routes come into question: an advertisement in the collectors' forum (free of charge but limited reach, especially not international), an eBay auction (large reach but high fees) and sale via professional dealers. The latter is, especially for more expensive pieces like the Imperial Dragon, recommendable, since specialised dealers have well-funded collector contacts and can take pieces on commission; usual is a commission. As proven contacts, Tom Westerich and Lutz Fiebig are named, both reachable via penboard.de.


Why does a Montblanc Meisterstück LeGrand rollerball only start writing after "persuasion", leak or fail after a few days, and could it be down to the cap?

It cannot definitely be due to the cap. Frequent causes are dried-up refills that have already been stored longer in specialist trade; Marathon refills do not necessarily last longer than standard refills. Start-up problems of this extent are very unusual, which is why individual factors like writing angle, imprint, paper as well as consistent closing after use are to be checked. A well-founded judgement is ultimately only possible if rollerball, refill and user are jointly assessed in a boutique. Until then, the rollerball should always be kept closed and not too strongly pressed.


Does a black Montblanc mechanical pencil No. 10 K from the year 1935 exist, and how rare is it?

Mechanical pencils with the model number 10 K were made at Montblanc between 1925 and 1939. In black hard-rubber version they are not a particularly rare collector's piece, unlike the variants in silver or gold, which are significantly rarer. A fixed price of 400 euros for the black model is therefore ambitious and not justifiable by rarity.


Is a "Mont Blanc Meisterstück ballpoint, near-new" offered on eBay genuine or a counterfeit, and can Montblanc legally proceed against sellers of counterfeits?

The ballpoint offered under eBay article number 112440688012 is unambiguously a counterfeit; in particular, the engraving shown does not exist in this form, and the rings are not correct. Sellers of such pieces are often "newcomers" without sales history who know exactly what they are offering. Montblanc does not proceed against every auction but forwards, after targeted hints, auctions with counterfeits to lawyers, which can become very unpleasant and expensive for sellers. Buyers should consistently keep their distance from such offers.


How can inherited writing instruments like a supposed Meisterstück 144 and a ballpoint 164 be identified and which sale prices are realistic?

A reliable model determination is not possible without meaningful pictures; descriptions and comparisons with the model pictures on the homepage, however, help with prior assignment. For value determination of relatively young writing instruments, forums are not the right place; the real market value is most likely ascertained by an eBay auction with a starting price of 1 euro, since higher starting prices experience-shows lead to lower closing prices. As a guideline, a Meisterstück 164 including papers and original packaging was sold on eBay for 135 euros; a LeGrand ballpoint typically lies at 180 to 200 euros. Prerequisites are good photos and a correct description based on the model specifications.


Can the length of a Montblanc Meisterstück in millimetres be derived from the model number (e.g. 146 for LeGrand)?

On some 146 examples the model number actually approximately agrees with the length in millimetres; however, this is no general rule and does not apply to all models or product types. Thus, e.g., the ballpoint 164 is not 16.4 cm long. The dimensions of individual models have additionally slightly changed in the course of decades, which makes the model number as a length indication additionally unreliable. More plausible is the assumption that the numbering rather orients itself on the diameter or on the length-to-diameter ratio, without giving the exact diameter.


How does one further disassemble the piston mechanism of a Montblanc 146 after barrel and cork seal are already unscrewed, and is the repair of a defective mechanism worthwhile?

A completely broken rotary mechanism of the 146 can practically not be repaired in a reasonable cost-benefit ratio, since often the second sleeve at the front towards the cork seal is torn. Before further disassembly steps, first the year of manufacture should be determined and the defect precisely localised, e.g. based on photos or comparison pictures of known collector sites. On reassembly, the new cork must be set with the mechanism screwed in, since from behind there is no access; tightness is the decisive criterion. Overall, the repair counts as very elaborate; a 142 can be restored comparatively more easily.


Does Montblanc really no longer make really thin-writing EF nibs, or with a nib exchange is a real extra-fine line width to be expected?

The claim that Montblanc no longer makes thin-writing EF nibs is not accurate; between M, F and EF a clear difference must be recognisable. If an exchanged nib does not write like an EF, it should be complained about and exchanged again. The perceived line thickness depends additionally strongly on the paper used: smooth test pads in boutiques as well as dipping the nib into ink during test writing make the stroke appear thicker than on usual writing paper. On normal paper, the difference to nibs of other brands is mostly significantly smaller.


Which model is a Montblanc ballpoint that is merely marked with "Mont Blanc - Germany" and bears no further type information?

It is a ballpoint from the Montblanc Slim Line or SL series, recognisable by the plastic logo in the clip; not from the Noblesse range, as a frequently cited book wrongly states. The new price was then below ten DM; the model is therefore no high-quality collector's piece but is suitable as an everyday-suitable writing instrument. It can be difficult to still procure matching ballpoint refills; in the forum there are tips on this. In literature and on relevant websites, Noblesse and SlimLine are repeatedly confused, so source statements are critically to be checked.


Why can private messages suddenly no longer be opened or displayed in the community's PMS system, although the inbox reports full mailboxes?

The problem occurs regularly when the shared email storage fills up because many users do not delete old messages. It is therefore asked to manually remove no-longer-needed messages so that the system works smoothly again. Additionally, the current PMS system is no longer up to the increased usage volume, which is why a replacement by a new system has already been announced, whose availability however is still pending. Until then, the PMS function should only be used restrictedly.


Is it possible to exchange the F nib of a new Montblanc Marcel Proust for an M nib, and what costs or restrictions are to be expected?

A nib change is basically only possible directly at Montblanc; independent workshops do not come into question. With the Marcel Proust, however, the exchange counts according to the boutique's information as not feasible, since no replacement nibs are kept in stock. In 2002, writing instruments with high limitation numbers and F nib turned up again, but only in this one nib strength. A cost-effective alternative would be to find someone willing to undertake a private nib exchange.


Is a writing set offered as "Opera de Paris" a known brand or rather an advertising article without collector value?

The set offered is no renowned brand product but an advertising article of a no-name manufacturer, presumably from Chinese production with the model name "Opera de Paris". The fountain pen is at most equipped with a gilded steel nib, so neither high-quality nor worth collecting. Optically the set may appear appealing; for writing it counts as unsuitable. Even the seller himself conceded on enquiry that they are merely simple promotional utensils.


How can an older celluloid piston fountain pen with Bock Heidelberg nib and the marking "LM" be unambiguously identified?

Bock nibs were fitted in a multitude of writing instruments, so the nib alone allows no assignment. Until the end of the Second World War, there were several hundred manufacturers in Germany, of which most are unknown today. If the fountain pen itself bears no unambiguous manufacturer marking, an identification is hardly possible; the letters "LM" also do not necessarily help further. An additional point of contact for such enquiries is the forum penexchange.de.


How can light scratches on the surface of a Carbon Steel fountain pen be reduced or removed?

It is recommended to present the writing instrument to a jeweller and have the metal professionally polished. From commercially available polishes like Wenol it is advised against, since they are too coarse for the fine surface and can experience-shows significantly worsen the appearance after application.


What is the auction of nibs in favour of press freedom by Reporters Without Borders about?

Reporters Without Borders auctioned between 19 and 29 October 2006 six high-quality fountain pens with handwritten dedications by prominent writers, actors and journalists on eBay in the section "Stars & Charity". Patronages were taken over, among others, by Julia Jentsch, Ulrich Wickert, Marietta Slomka, Henning Mankell, Harry Rowohlt and Reinhold Beckmann. The campaign was supported by Pelikan, Faber-Castell, Cleo, Waterman and Parker. The proceeds went to the worldwide engagement of the organisation for freedom of the press and opinion.


Are the Montblanc perfumes and face waters offered in eBay auctions in strikingly simple packaging really original goods or frequently counterfeits?

The plain, cheap-looking packagings do not correspond to the usual get-up of Montblanc fragrances as can be seen in official channels like Douglas or on the Montblanc website. Original fragrances like Individuel, Présence or StarWalker are described in full there and labelled with product names. On eBay, the proportion of counterfeit perfumes is generally very high, and the imitations including packaging are by now so well made that they are hardly recognisable on photos. With the offers mentioned, counterfeits are therefore most likely to be assumed; in fact, often only water with Montblanc imprint is sold.


How can two presumably older Montblanc cartridge fountain pens without further model designation be assigned to a concrete model based on the nib image, cap and serial number?

The first pen with completely golden nib and flat ends can presumably be assigned to the Generation range or a model range around the mid/end of the 1970s; it is rather an entry-level model with correspondingly low collector value. The second writing instrument with two-tone gold nib and inscription "Meisterstück" belongs to the Classique range, presumably a 144 (recognisable by the plug-on cap). Today usually only on the 149 is the model number engraved on the cap ring; older examples often bear no visible model statement. Via the serial number engraved under the clip (e.g. CG235...), the production date can be enquired about with Montblanc customer service, which helps with narrowing down the model.


What distinguishes the variant Montblanc Meisterstück Ultra Black, and what are the so-called "Bespoke" nibs?

The variant is characterised by rhodium-plated trim and clip as well as a matt surface and counts as visually particularly appealing. The nib engraving too stands out positively compared to the engravings on the body. "Bespoke" nibs designate nibs individually made for the customer, e.g. in special grinds like Soft B. Such a special nib alone weighs in at about 1,000 euros.


Can a Montblanc Meisterstück 144 be genuine although no serial number is engraved in the clip ring?

A missing serial number in the clip ring is on older 144s no authenticity exclusion, since Montblanc only introduced consistent numbering from a later point. Original features are, among others, the inscription "Pix" under the clip, a completely gold nib without platinum intarsia as well as a flat feed, which additionally points to an older example. The 144 was, after the relaunch of the Meisterstück Classique size, delivered either as a cartridge or converter filler. With remaining doubts, a direct picture comparison and the search for older forum discussions help further.


Which hints and what price range are to be considered in the private sale of a rare Montblanc Masterpiece 146G in grey striped?

For a serious sale enquiry in the forum, clear information is indispensable: salutation with first names, meaningful pictures (ideally with a note bearing the seller's name in the picture) and a concrete price expectation. In the specific case, a guideline price of about 1,100 euros was named by another collector. In the forum it is additionally pointed out that private auction-style offers à la eBay are seen critically, since the forum is not primarily intended to achieve maximum prices.


What total length does a Montblanc Meisterstück 146 from the 1980s have?

A 146 with monochrome golden nib, which usually indicates a manufacture between about 1987 and 1992, shows a total length of 14.2 cm. This value matches already documented dimension specifications on Meisterstück writing instruments since the 1980s.


In which material variants did the Montblanc Bohème Je t'aime exist and in what price range did these lie?

The Bohème Je t'aime existed in several versions: of black precious resin (resin), of sterling silver as well as of white gold, in each case as cartridge fountain pen and ballpoint. The precious-resin variant is a real version made by Montblanc but no longer appears on the Montblanc website today, since the series was discontinued. The white-gold version was around 11,000 euros per piece and had hearts of real rubies on the clip. Current prices for the other variants can most reliably be enquired about directly with Montblanc or in a boutique.


From what time did Montblanc introduce the serial number in the clip ring, and why does an older 165 Solitaire silver pencil bear only the inscription "W.Germany"?

On this recurring question there are already several forum threads in which the introduction of clip-ring serial numbers has been discussed in detail. Answers can be found most quickly via the search function with the keyword "Seriennummer". A missing serial number is not unusual for older examples and no authenticity exclusion.


Which Montblanc model is an attic find that externally recalls the Noblesse range, and what value is realistic?

The writing instrument found is a Montblanc Quickpen, an independent, inexpensive model without reference to Noblesse or Slim Line. The original retail price was DM 19.50 including a felt-tip and a roller refill. High-priced auction offers for comparable pens are completely excessive; such "moon prices" appear frequently but are rarely achieved. The Quickpen is thus no valuable collector's piece but a usable original Montblanc.


How can one ascertain by hallmarks and engravings whether an inherited Montblanc ballpoint with "Meisterstück" inscription is genuine?

Indications of an original are in particular hallmarks with precious-metal specifications (e.g. 585, 750, 925 or 950) on the cap area. An engraving of the inscription "Meisterstück" on the gilded tip from which the refill emerges is, by contrast, untypical and rather indicates a counterfeit, since on a real Montblanc usually no inscription is placed there. An unambiguous judgement succeeds best based on clear detail photos of the cap rings, the hallmarks and the named engraving spots.


What experiences are there with Montblanc accessories like travel bottles, manicure sets and stainless-steel razors, and what possibilities for personalisation exist?

The large travel bottle holds 170 ml, the small one 85 ml. The stainless-steel razor is compatible with Mach3 blades, so no special Montblanc blades are necessary. Travel bottles, shoe-polish and shaving accessories cannot be engraved themselves; only the product packaging can be provided with initials. The manicure set can be embossed from inside, with all embossings being done at the factory or by sending in to Montblanc.


Is the entry into Montblanc writing instruments with an unexpectedly acquired piece worthwhile, and how can authenticity be reliably checked?

A reliable authenticity check is most sensibly carried out directly in a Montblanc boutique, where the fountain pen can be inspected and judged. Often the first Montblanc becomes the entry into a more extensive collection, since the appeal of such writing instruments experience-shows quickly entails further purchases. Collectors point out that the packaging also delivers hints about the age of a writing instrument. Accompanying this, original ink is often acquired, e.g. in Sepia, in order to undertake the first writing attempts.


How can an older push-button fountain pen with the inscription "4810 Montblanc Meisterstück" and a barely legible DRP number be unambiguously assigned to a model?

For identification of a push-button Meisterstück from this era, especially the model number on the turning knob at the rear end is decisive, e.g. 20, 25 or 30. Dimensions like length and diameter alone do not suffice for a reliable assignment. If the number on the turning knob is no longer legible due to signs of use, the exact model determination can experience-shows fail even with a magnifier. Inscription, nib engraving and brand name on the cap merely confirm the rough belonging to the Meisterstück range.


What can be the cause that on a Montblanc Writers Edition William Faulkner between the metal ring and the precious resin ink leaks out and causes inky fingers?

During normal writing no inky fingers should arise; if between the front metal ring and grip section ink emerges, a defect is to be assumed that cannot be unambiguously diagnosed without inspection. It is recommended to present the writing instrument to a Montblanc boutique or to Montblanc service. The repair by Montblanc service worked reliably in the specific case; an initially issued invoice was generously handled in the boutique. If after filling ink first emerges, this can at least temporarily be controlled by carefully wiping the area (e.g. with a tissue); if fine scratches later arise on the grip section, these can be caused by putting on or screwing on the cap.


Are rust spots on the silver-coloured nib carrier of a Montblanc Bohème a known problem, and how should one proceed?

On the very first Bohème writing instruments, rust problems demonstrably existed, which were remedied in later production series, since Montblanc exchanged the entire inner workings against rust-free components. Anyone noticing rust spots should contact Montblanc customer service; in comparable cases repairs were carried out free of charge as a gesture of goodwill. Alternatively, the writing instrument could also be restored by experienced repairers, e.g. by polishing the end ring and loosening the front sleeve screwing, but first the official Montblanc service should be used. "Normal" rust is on a Bohème in no way to be expected.


Can a Bordeaux Montblanc 146 Le Grand already bear a serial number in the clip ring, or does this variant basically exist only without a number?

The 146 in Bordeaux existed not only until 1990 but significantly longer; production ran for at least ten more years, and in the trade corresponding writing instruments often still lay for many years. Therefore real Bordeaux Le Grand models exist both without and with serial number in the clip ring, and a serial number is no indication of a counterfeit. The acquisition of a Bordeaux 146 with serial number is thus unhesitating.


Did the Pelikan 140 exist in two different sizes, or can an apparently larger example be a mixed construction?

The Pelikan 140 was made from 1955 to 1963 in a uniform size; the total length of about 12.5 cm named in collector sources is consistent. A significantly longer example with 13.1 cm and a deviating piston mechanism or feed is therefore no "large 140" but generally a barrel from the 400 range, on which a 140 cap was subsequently placed. The concrete 400 barrel can, based on the feed, probably be dated to the 1970s. The identification of Pelikan models is overall due to frequent parts combinations confusing.


Is on the Montblanc 146 "75 Years of Passion and Soul" the brilliant in the "O" of the inscription correctly twisted by 180 degrees opposite the clip, or can this be corrected?

The brilliant should at delivery state actually not be offset by 180 degrees opposite the clip; such a position is especially with a limited edition unusual and suggests that after delivery manipulation took place. A correction is possible and can be carried out directly on the spot in Montblanc boutiques.


Are there suitable converters for the Caran d'Ache Ecridor XS, and how strict is the requirement to use only original cartridges?

For the compact fountain pen Ecridor XS there are no suitable converters, since the construction height needed for the filling mechanism would reduce the ink volume unreasonably. The section is also specially shaped, so only original Caran d'Ache cartridges fit precisely. In practice, cartridges of other manufacturers (e.g. Visconti) can partly also be used without problems, but with deviating dimensions there is a risk of leakage and ink stains. Anyone wanting to be on the safe side uses the manufacturer's original cartridges.


Is the purchase of a Montblanc Meisterstück 149 worthwhile for someone who writes only very rarely and predominantly fills in forms, postcards or money transfers?

For the applications mentioned like money transfers, postcards or parcel slips, a fountain pen is actually unsuitable, since conventional ink runs with moisture and can be altered with ink killer; here a ballpoint or a fountain pen with document-proof ink is more sensible. Nevertheless, nothing speaks against acquiring the 149, since writing with ink has its own appeal and can stimulate the discovery of diary, calligraphy or handwritten correspondence. To be noted, however, is that the 149 is too large for many shirt pockets and is therefore more suitable as a stationary writing instrument at the desk; in mobile work situations, models like LeGrand or Classique are more practicable. Dryness or leakage are with proper care and regular use no noteworthy problem.


Does the accompanying brochure of the Montblanc Agatha Christie have the same format as that of the Hemingway, or do the originals differ?

The Hemingway brochure is actually larger than the accompanying brochures of other Writers Edition writing instruments; the larger format thus corresponds to the original and is no indication of a deviating or non-genuine document.


Are there affordable alternatives for the repair of a Montblanc 244 with a disintegrated cork seal if the Montblanc quotation lies at around 310 euros?

The price set by Montblanc is high but can be explained by warranty service as well as the effort for procurement of the no-longer-used cork seals. Significantly cheaper are generally specialised independent repair workshops and experienced collectors who offer such restorations. An overview of corresponding workshops can be found in the forum under the section "Reparatur". With comparable result, the effort with these specialists, and thus also the price, is mostly considerably lower.


Why does a Montblanc pencil of the range DB 02 or DB 01 in one variant bear a star on the turning knob, in the other however not?

Without high-quality detail pictures, the difference cannot be unambiguously explained; one possibility is that the cap on one of the pencils is missing, which on some models makes the star appear removed. There are actually Montblanc pencils (e.g. of hard rubber, with cap) on which the body itself bears no star. The DB pencils are with about 8 cm length very small and presumably designed for address or notebooks. A final judgement requires the writing instrument in hand, since photos often do not adequately reproduce such details.


Can one ascertain solely on the basis of the serial number of a Montblanc Meisterstück Solitaire Stainless Steel whether the writing instrument is genuine?

The meaning of the serial numbers is secret; therefore only Montblanc or an authorised specialist retailer can bindingly check the authenticity. Counterfeits also frequently bear serial numbers, so the mere existence of a number has no meaning. A positive indication is when the serial number is laser-engraved ("grey") and not stamped; certainty, however, is only brought by presentation to the specialist retailer. If the number begins with an "8" instead of with the letter "B", a counterfeit is to be assumed, since originals use corresponding letter prefixes.


Has Montblanc ever officially offered a black Bohème ballpoint with a white or transparent stone in the clip?

A Bohème with a transparent stone Montblanc has offered exclusively in the model Bohème Platinum Crystal, that is, not in the black variant. With a black Bohème with a white stone in the clip, a counterfeit is therefore to be assumed. Additional indications of this are untidy transitions between cap top, clip and cap; on the original these components close flush. A definitive clarification can be made by Montblanc service.


Can a gifted Montblanc Meisterstück with the engraving "Pix" and "Montblanc Meisterstück Pix" on the ring be classified as an original despite a missing serial number?

The writing instrument is most likely an original, presumably a Montblanc Meisterstück 164 (ballpoint), available, among others, in gold and platinum version. A missing serial number can have various reasons: on writing instruments made before 1991 there was not yet consistent numbering; occasionally the number was simply forgotten to be laser-engraved during production. The engravings "Pix" under the clip and "Montblanc Meisterstück Pix" on the ring are characteristic features of an original.


How can a Montblanc 144 acquired on eBay be reliably verified as an original, and which inks are unproblematic?

An authenticity check most likely succeeds through careful comparison with documented features as well as assessment based on clear detail photos; in the specific case, the fountain pen was classified from description and pictures as 100 percent genuine. A reputable eBay purchase including personal handover is quite possible, even if the risk of counterfeits remains real. Unproblematic are water-soluble standard inks like the original Montblanc ink; non-water-soluble inks can on longer idle time clog up the feed. Iron-gall inks (blue-black) are also to be seen critically, since they can contain acidic components (formerly even sulphuric or hydrochloric acid).


What experiences exist with fountain pens of the brand Danitrio, especially with models with Maki-e lacquer decorations?

Concrete experience reports on Maki-e models by Danitrio are only restrictedly available; available are experiences with an eyedropper fountain pen with Tamenuri finish, which corresponds to the typical size (Mikado) of the Danitrio Maki-e models. The procurement took place via internetpens.net (Bevin Cheng), with advice and service being positively highlighted. Statements on the price-performance ratio of the actual Maki-e models, however, remain open.


Is an offered Montblanc that at first glance looks like a counterfeit actually counterfeit or a real Mozart?

On closer examination it is an entirely normal, original Montblanc Mozart from the Meisterstück range. The optical similarity to known counterfeits stems from the fact that the model is shown on many relevant comparison sites together with plagiarisms. Anyone who does not know the model can therefore easily mistake it for a counterfeit, which in the specific case led to a misjudgement.


Are the Montblanc models 254 and 24, which do not appear on relevant collector sites, nevertheless independent versions?

Both models are documented in collector literature: the Montblanc 254, similarly to the 252, was made between 1954 and 1959 in various versions; the Montblanc 24 was produced parallel to the 22 between 1960 and 1970. For further research the search functions of collector forums like penexchange.de are recommended, even if there search terms like "Montblanc 24" are partly ignored due to too-frequent occurrence. Collectors' meet-ups, e.g. get-togethers in the Pforzheim region, offer additional possibilities for knowledge exchange.


Which German-language, private and non-commercial collector websites with well-founded contents on the subject of writing instruments are recommendable?

Recommended are especially maxpens.de, the site by Werner Rüttinger (ruettinger-web.de) as well as top-pens.de by Gerhard Baur. For specialised topics, waterman-kirkel.com (Volker Köhl, Waterman) and bleistiftsammler.de are insightful. An extended overview can also be found in the Open Directory Project under the section Schreibgeräte as well as in the link collection of the forum. Decisive is that the site really conveys collector information and does not primarily serve own trade.


Can the electronics of a laser pointer be built into the housing of a Montblanc writing instrument, and is there a sensible alternative to the DIY solution?

A DIY conversion of a Montblanc Le Grand ballpoint to a laser pointer is technically conceivable but, among other things, due to the certifications required in Germany for laser pointers, legally problematic. As an alternative, ready laser pointers in form and look of a LeGrand ballpoint exist, e.g. the "Photon Ultimate", which have a laser-beam exit instead of the star as well as a rotary mechanism as on a real ballpoint. These are partly obtainable via international platforms, with shipping conditions and possible customs fees to be heeded. Thus a visually coherent overall picture can be achieved without modifying an original writing instrument.


Which costs are to be expected for the exchange of a cap on a Montblanc Meisterstück 145 via the Montblanc service, and is a repair basically sensible?

Repairs on newer Montblanc writing instruments, including the cap exchange, can be carried out exclusively via Montblanc itself (possibly mediated by an authorised dealer). In the specific case of the 145, a price of 85 euros for the cap exchange was named by phone, which compared to the acquisition of a complete replacement pen is a sensible option. Generally, however, spare-part prices are often very high, and with some repairs, e.g. small damages on gilded rings, three-digit to high quotes are possible. Before a repair, the offered price should therefore always be compared with the costs of used writing instruments.


How can it be explained that a Montblanc Meisterstück 144 in Bordeaux with solid-gold nib is engraved on the clip ring not with "W-Germany" but only with "Germany"?

The change of the engraving from "W-Germany" to "Germany" took place in October 1990, while the black-grip-section variant with solid-gold nib was mainly made in the middle of the 1980s. A plausible explanation is that within a repair by Montblanc the clip or the entire cap was exchanged for a then-available spare part; writing instruments with temporally "mixed" components are therefore not unusual. A subsequent cap exchange by a dealer is also conceivable, especially since the cap of the 144 is susceptible due to its thin material. The writing instrument thus basically remains a real Montblanc but combines components from different production phases.


Are there besides Montblanc other manufacturers that have produced fountain pens with a brass telescopic filling system?

The screw-telescopic system originally goes back to Luxor (H. Herborn), who developed corresponding mechanisms of hard rubber or aluminium. Reform made push-telescopic mechanisms which, however, deviate structurally. Montblanc itself did not invent the telescopic system but only contributed to the further development of the guidance; according to current knowledge, Montblanc is today the only provider with a brass telescope fitted in this form. An identical mechanism of other current brands is not known.


What should a newcomer pay attention to when buying a Montblanc Meisterstück LeGrand, and which care and filling instructions are to be heeded?

The first Montblanc should as far as possible be bought in specialist trade and not on the internet, since only there advice on nib width, size and handling is possible; an unsuitable nib width reduces the writing enjoyment independently of the quality of the fountain pen. With test writing it is recommended to bring one's own paper and to take one's time. Filling takes place by unscrewing, dipping the nib in the ink bottle, drawing up and wiping off excess ink at the grip section; an illustrated instruction can be found in the supplied warranty and service booklet. Royal-blue, water-soluble inks are unproblematic; other inks require regular flushing before drying out; otherwise the care is with proper use minimal.


Are there Montblanc fountain pens that can optionally be filled with cartridges or an exchangeable piston converter, and what size category do they fall into?

Models like the Meisterstück Classique range, especially the 144 and 145, can be filled optionally with cartridges or a piston converter. The 144 Classique is with about 11.8 cm open or 13.5 cm closed length the second-smallest representative of the Meisterstück construction range. Writing experiences with the 144 in nib width BB are described as butter-soft and with good start-up behaviour, in connection with original Montblanc ink. The 144 has been taken from the regular programme by now but is available used in private and auction markets.


How can one recognise a supposedly old Montblanc set that was actually subsequently "Montblanc-ised", and how does a seller deal with corresponding hints?

Indications of a subsequent brand counterfeit are, among others, a logo that does not correspond in size, placement or plasticity to the known Montblanc conventions, as well as a star with a white ring that has only been used in recent times and therefore does not fit a declared old set. Complementarily, comparison with Montblanc stickers from today can indicate pure sticker application on old pieces. Atypical style elements that fit no documented original product of the stated era are an additional warning sign. If a seller reacts to corresponding factual hints demonstratively dismissively or insultingly, this is a further indication that it is not a reputable original auction.


Is it correct that on the Montblanc Writers Edition Fitzgerald the actually white body shimmers amber on some examples?

The body of the Fitzgerald edition (ArtDeco) was originally made in white; brownish or amber-coloured shimmers arise when the plastic was over a longer time exposed to UV radiation, e.g. in illuminated shop windows. On some examples, however, the discolouration affects the entire body evenly and not only the one-sidedly exposed side, which can indicate further material influences or even storage in light. It is no separate production variant but an age-related discolouration. Originally, the Fitzgerald exists in clear white and in differently strongly browned intermediate stages.


How can inherited fountain pens and mechanical pencils with silver body without recognisable brand be classified, and can defective filling mechanisms be repaired?

A judgement of model, manufacturer and value is hardly possible without pictures, since construction and filling system (e.g. removable overlay, ink tank, converter) cannot be reconciled without inspection. It is therefore recommended to post detail photos of the writing instruments so construction and filling system can be precisely determined. Only on this basis can statements be made on the quality, on the potential value and on sensible repair routes for the no-longer-rotatable converters.


Is it worth repairing a Montblanc 146 with a broken-off ring on the barrel oneself, or should one leave that to a specialist?

A self-repair of a Montblanc 146 is basically not recommended, since special tools and several years' experience are required. Especially the newer 146s are difficult to repair, so they should rather be given to the specialist retailer or directly to Montblanc. Montblanc often exchanges such parts without problem within the warranty. A simple gluing on of the broken-off ring is not advisable, because this component anchors the nib and is sealed with silicone against the housing.


Is a Schiller set offered in the USA via an Italian provider an original good, and is the price reasonable?

The Schiller set shown looks authentic based on the pictures. The called-up price of over 1100 euros is, however, too high, since the Schiller edition is regularly still led in many shops and is thus cheaper to obtain. Even the shipping costs of around 27 euros and the unclear exchange rate in US dollars speak against the purchase from this provider. The same seller had previously offered a complete display box of 146s for 1500 euros without finding a taker. A purchase in Germany is therefore safer and generally cheaper.


Is it normal that the rotary mechanism of a new Montblanc Bohème noir fountain pen scratches when extending the nib?

A scratching noise when extending the nib is on the Bohème not normal and mostly indicates ink residues in the rotary mechanism. If the fountain pen was only recently bought (within the warranty period), an exchange at the seller is recommended. If a careful cleaning does not help, the device should be sent to service at Montblanc.


Is there a matching mechanical pencil (Pix) for the Montblanc 244?

A Pix belonging directly to the Montblanc 244 is not known. As a visually fitting supplement, a model 272 with identical clip comes most likely into question.


Are photos of a Montblanc Andrew Carnegie 4810 desired for a picture collection in the forum/on fountainpen.de?

Missing photos of writing instruments are always welcome for the website, especially of editions for which no pictures yet exist. Owing to high professional workload of the webmaster, posting can however take a longer time. Contributions by collectors are gladly accepted and will gradually be integrated into the overview.

Related pages on fountainpen.de:
• Patron of Arts Andrew Carnegie: https://www.fountainpen.de/patron-carnegie-4810-en.htm


How can a damaged vintage Montblanc 139 be repaired whose rear end shows a crack and a worn thread?

A Montblanc 139 with a cracked sleeve and broken-out thread can be saved through a special repair by shortening the barrel and reducing it in diameter in order to install a new sleeve with stepped bore and thread. In the case described here this was implemented in so-called Hemingway style with a red hard-rubber sleeve; a visually original-true variant in black would alternatively be possible. The method counts as suitable to make heavily damaged vintage models functional again and is visually accepted by the owner, provided the effort is fully documented.


When were Montblanc 146 fountain pens delivered in a simple cardboard box instead of in the padded clamshell box?

Until about 1993, factory-new Montblanc writing instruments were delivered to specialist retailers in a works packaging of thin cardboard; this, however, did not serve as sales packaging but was exchanged when sold against the higher-quality gift box. Today, delivery takes place in blister packaging. Such a cardboard box is therefore an original packaging and no indication of a preceding repair. Only earlier comparable cardboard boxes were occasionally also used by service for return transport, which however allows no conclusion about the condition of the pen.


Can it happen that on eBay offers only the packaging is counterfeit but the fountain pen itself looks genuine?

In the case described, not only is the packaging with black star counterfeit but the fountain pen itself too. Unambiguous indication is the nib with the inscription Iridium Point Germany, which would never be found on a real Montblanc. Structural details like the missing thread on the grip section (only plugged in instead of screwed) also expose the counterfeit as a typical LeGrand imitation. More difficult is recognition with StarWalker or Bohème counterfeits, which are on photos hardly distinguishable from originals but in hand are immediately noticeable. Pleasing is that Montblanc and eBay are increasingly successfully removing such offers.


How should one evaluate an eBay fountain pen whose packaging is obviously counterfeit but the pen itself on the pictures still looks genuine?

If the packaging is recognisably counterfeit, one should basically keep one's distance from the purchase, even if the fountain pen still appears genuine on the mostly deliberately detail-poor photos. On closer inspection, e.g., the grip section often does not look original-true, and the assured properties cannot be verified based on poor pictures. Even if the seller acts in good faith, that does not protect the buyer legally and financially. The risk of receiving a fake is in such cases simply too great.


Is the picture collection of Montblanc fountain pens on fountainpen.de still being extended, and are submitted photos welcome?

The picture overview is continuously being extended, and contributions by collectors are expressly welcome. Owing to strong professional workload of the webmaster, the incorporation can however take a longer time, since several hundred not-yet-posted photos are already available. Anyone wishing to contribute their own shots can send in a list of available writing instruments, after which it is decided which pictures are still needed.


What value does an original three-piece set of the Montblanc Writers Edition Edgar Allan Poe have?

Complete three-piece sets of the Edgar Allan Poe Edition have occasionally been auctioned for around 1600 euros, which is rather at the upper end of the market price. Value-determining are in particular the completeness of the papers, the condition of the writing instruments and the presence of consistently identical serial numbers (limited to 3000). General hints on value determination of writing instruments can be found in corresponding forum threads. A realistic market price lies rather below the achieved peak values.


Does a rollerball variant of the Montblanc Imperial Dragon exist?

A rollerball from the Imperial Dragon range has never existed. From the Imperial Dragon only fountain pens in two variants, a ballpoint and a pencil appeared. Every piece offered as Imperial Dragon rollerball is thus necessarily a counterfeit and typically corresponds to an imitation produced in China for a few euros.


Has Montblanc produced briefcases from the Meisterstück series also in brown, or are all exclusively black?

The leather bags from the Meisterstück series were made exclusively in black. Brown leather articles by Montblanc do indeed exist in other collections like the West or Eastside line, but a briefcase from the Meisterstück line in brown is not known. The brown bag offered in the concrete case on eBay is therefore most likely a counterfeit.


How can a Montblanc ballpoint designated as Solitaire Vermeil without a hallmark be dated and classified materially?

A piece without a precious-metal imprint is no real vermeil (gilded silver) but merely gilded brass; even real solid-gold writing instruments always bear a corresponding hallmark (585 or 750). The absence of a serial number and the sole engraving Germany point to a model from the time before 1991, since Montblanc only introduced serial numbers from this year. It is therefore an older version of the Solitaire Korn in gilded brass. This information can be confirmed by the relevant Solitaire Vermeil Korn overview on fountainpen.de.


Why can a long post composed in the forum suddenly be lost on sending?

Responsible is usually the temporary login in the forum: with longer inactivity, the user is automatically logged out for security reasons, so on sending the post is lost. Anyone wishing to avoid this should activate at login the option "I want to remain logged in". Additionally, network settings on one's own computer can cause problems, e.g. when the MTU value of a WLAN router is set over 1400; in such cases no posts can be made any more.


How does one recognise on a Montblanc 149 (or 146) offered on eBay whether it is genuine, especially when the nib embossing appears unusual?

If the description does not clearly identify the model as a 149 and the nib does not fit the rest of the construction (for example 14C embossing on a supposed 146), one should for safety reasons keep one's distance. With real new Meisterstück nibs, the edges are covered with gold and the centre with platinum. Particular caution is in order when a seller uses foreign photos, e.g. pictures stolen from fountainpen.de; such auctions are ended via the eBay VeRO programme. Generally it is recommended, when buying, to accept only own photos and plausible seller histories and in case of doubt rather to acquire from trustworthy collectors in the forum.


Is a Pelikan depicted on the internet a vintage model or a modern reissue?

The piece shown is most likely the Pelikan M200 Retroset, which appeared as a reissue some years ago. It is thus no real vintage version but a modern reedition in classic design.


Did Montblanc 146 fountain pens with a monochrome 14-carat gold nib exist, and are these authentic?

Yes, real Montblanc 146s from the late 1970s exist that were delivered exclusively with a monochrome 14-carat yellow-gold nib. The absence of the bicolour nib is therefore no sign of a counterfeit. The inner mechanism (piston in metal version) as well as the imprint 4810 14K confirm the authenticity. Fastening details like the cap top screwed in from inside are also typical structural features of the period.


How old is a Montblanc Pix 350 mechanical pencil with the inscription Germany, and is the metal used real gold?

The Montblanc 350 was made from 1971 to 1984 and is relatively frequently encountered. Clip and rings are not of real gold but only gilded; only models with the hallmark 585 or 750 actually contain solid gold. Until 1991, Montblanc was a normal writing-instrument manufacturer with a broad range from school supplies to the Meisterstück and positioned itself as a luxury brand only thereafter, which is why the 350 today has no very high material value. As a sentimental memorial object or as a utility piece, however, it can nevertheless be valued.


Where and in what form is the Montblanc Egyptomania Edition available?

The Egyptomania Edition is available both on the French and on the German Montblanc website; only ink and pen pouch of the range are partly not depicted there. The edition is visually judged very positively; some, however, feel the fountain pen, due to its comparatively narrow diameter, as too thin. Anyone preferring thicker fountain pens may not find the ideal size here.


Is an eBay rollerball with strikingly pointed star corners despite a serial number and heavy weight an original?

A star with unnaturally pointed corners is a clear counterfeit feature; equally typical are visible furrows between the three cap rings. Despite a serial number and higher weight, it is therefore a counterfeit. Detailed comparison overviews of typical counterfeit features can be found on fountainpen.de, e.g. in the PDF comparison of rollerball counterfeits. Anyone buying a Montblanc at strikingly low prices or from disreputable providers should reckon with counterfeits.


When is a Montblanc warranty card issued without filled-in fields for model and clip-ring number, and what meaning does it have?

Such incompletely filled-in warranty cards often come from internal employee sales in which MB employees acquire writing instruments at special conditions and partly resell them, which is observable above all in November and December on eBay. Since Montblanc by the serial number typically captures only the manufacturing date, not the purchase date, cards without entered model and clip-ring number theoretically suit several writing instruments. Precisely for this reason they can be misused for sale together with counterfeits, especially since blank warranty cards and packagings are at times auctioned on eBay. By now, warranty cards themselves are also being counterfeited, so even filled-in cards are no reliable authenticity proof. Certainty offers ultimately only purchase from specialist trade or from known sellers.


What size does the Montblanc Meisterstück offered in the Lufthansa Worldshop have, and how does it compare to a Pelikan M600 or M800?

The writing instrument offered in the Lufthansa Worldshop is a Montblanc 145 (Platinum Line Classique). In direct comparison, a Pelikan 620, for example, is somewhat thicker; in overall size, both, however, are not far apart. Anyone seeking a fountain pen roughly in the size range of an M600 to M800 will find in the 145 a comparable, slightly slimmer counterpart.


Is a cheaply offered, near-new set of the Writers Edition Fitzgerald on eBay trustworthy or rather a counterfeit?

Based on the available hints, nothing speaks against the Fitzgerald set being genuine. The inner packaging equipped with cloth and holding clamps was standard at Montblanc until at least 2006 and is therefore no counterfeit indication. The original retail price in 2002 was around 1310 euros; the Fitzgerald edition does not count as particularly sought-after, which is why the currently called-up auction price is to be classified as market-customary but not as a bargain. To be noted is that the white material of the edition can over time yellow to an amber tone. With uncertainty, it is recommended to suggest the handover directly in a Montblanc boutique.


How can manufacturer, age and value of a fountain pen with gilded 18-carat overlay and an unknown brand name be determined?

The unknown brand name and the construction of the overlay point to Italian production; an unambiguous assignment is, however, difficult without further sources. Hints in the forum refer to the book by Jean Rösler, in which some small brands are described as sub-brands of known manufacturers like Montblanc. An exact dating and value estimate is only possible through direct comparison with similar Italian jewellery pens, which is why an enquiry in Italian collector forums is also worthwhile. With private manufacture without traceable maker, the value remains above all a material one (gold content of nib/overlay) as well as an emotional one.


How can a longer-stored unknown Montblanc fountain pen together with rollerballs be unambiguously identified?

Based on clear photos, the models can mostly be well determined: in the specific case, it is two Montblanc Meisterstück 163 rollerballs with a Sienna leather case as well as a school fountain pen which, according to information from Montblanc, is the model 422 from the Classic product family and was led between 1977 and 1984 (shop price 1984: 21 DM). For reliable identification, a look at the model overview on fountainpen.de and in case of doubt a direct enquiry to Montblanc customer service with photo are worthwhile. With forum entries, meaningful pictures in sufficient resolution should be supplied in order to avoid suppositions.


How does one recognise today a very well-made Montblanc Hematite counterfeit?

Even high-quality-looking Hematite counterfeits show classical weak points that stand out on closer examination. Typical indicators are a not-original-true designed body end, deviating rings, a poorly executed star and an unusually-looking nib. Even if the counterfeit deceives in overall impression, these detail differences can be used for recognition. Concrete proof photos of such auctions are generally only briefly available and protected by copyright.


Is it permissible to publish complete Montblanc price lists or individual prices on the internet?

The publication of complete Montblanc price lists on the internet is not permitted; corresponding posts are consistently deleted in the forum. Against naming an individual price on request Montblanc, by contrast, mostly has no objection. Responsible for compliance with these rules is in each case the webmaster or shop operator. Pure links to other sites are generally permissible, although the legal situation in some special cases remains unclear.